When is a CEQA EIR required?
Under the fair argument standard, if the lead agency is presented with a fair argument that the project may have a significant effect, it prepares an EIR, even if other evidence points the other way; controversy alone is not enough[12]. An initial study usually comes first[13].
The notice of preparation, scoping and AB 52 tribal consultation
The lead agency sends a notice of preparation (NOP) describing the project, location and probable effects to LCI (formerly OPR) and to responsible, trustee and federal agencies[3][14], which have 30 days to say what the EIR must cover[15]. Projects of statewide, regional or areawide significance need a scoping meeting[3].
Under AB 52, an affiliated tribe that asked in writing gets notice within 14 days of the application being complete or the agency deciding to proceed. It has 30 days to request consultation, which must start within 30 days and before the EIR is released[16].
Draft EIR review and the final EIR
With the draft EIR done, the lead agency files a notice of completion and gives public notice[17]. It must accept comments by email[18] and answer significant environmental issues in writing, sending responses to commenting agencies at least 10 days before certification[19]. The final EIR adds the comments and responses[20][21].
Example: Fresno County's EIR for Friant Ranch, about 2,500 homes on 942 acres, found significant and unavoidable air quality impacts, and the county approved it with a statement of overriding considerations. In December 2018 the California Supreme Court held the EIR inadequate because it did not explain the pollution's likely health effects[22].
Certification, findings and the notice of determination
Before approval, the lead agency certifies that the final EIR complies with CEQA and reflects its independent judgment[23]. For each significant effect it finds that changes avoid or substantially lessen it, another agency is responsible, or mitigation and alternatives are infeasible[24][25]. Unavoidable significant effects need a statement of overriding considerations[26].
Within five working days of approval, it files a notice of determination[4]: a local agency with the county clerk and State Clearinghouse, a state agency with LCI[27][28]. Filing starts a 30-day window for lawsuits[29].